The main theme throughout all of the nonsense that Access Ministries have been peddling, the one constant, immutable “fact” has been their claim to overwhelming public endorsement and support of their SRI and chaplaincy programs. In fact, their favourite number seems to be 98% – they even print glossy brochures about it (via SUQLD, 764kb .pdf). They throw all sorts of bogus numbers at you, but the magic 98% is by far their favourite.
These extraordinary boasts require extraordinary evidence, and Access have already thrown large amounts of cash at professional data torturers to extract the truth out of selectively harvested factoids – both Edith Cowan University and Social Compass, as previously discussed here. And to reiterate, I hold neither of these organisations to blame – they simply delivered product as defined by the customer scope, just a simple business transaction. Access wanted confirmation bias support, and that is what they got.
So let’s revisit this issue of the alleged massive support that Access have from the public then. Just over a month ago, with much hoopla, when the shit started hitting the fan, Access announced a new, improved Facebook Causes page and urged the masses to rise up and voice their disgust at the evil, child hating secularists. As observed at the time, this was hardly a roaring success. But never mind, it was probably a slow boil, and the people’s obvious support would arrive once the grass roots word of mouth campaign got in full swing. Wouldn’t it?
Here is a summary of the Cause since then –
Support Faith in Schools – members 2110
Up by about 200 since the current crisis first started (over 5 weeks ago) – the remainder being several years worth of members harvested from the old Access Ministries Facebook group.
This is their membership uptake from May 1 to now –
And the new sign ups over the last week –
Past Week
Date | Total Joins | Change from previous day |
---|---|---|
Sun, Jun 19 | 6 | +20.0% |
Sat, Jun 18 | 5 | -54.5% |
Fri, Jun 17 | 11 | +83.3% |
Thu, Jun 16 | 6 | -40.0% |
Wed, Jun 15 | 10 | +100.0% |
Tue, Jun 14 | 5 | -37.5% |
Mon, Jun 13 | 8 | +14.3% |
.
Impressive eh? And you have to bear in mind that this covers a period where Access CRE and chaplaincy have had almost daily media attention. In fact, these figures are so telling that Access Ministries no longer even advertises this Causes page on their own website’s support links. Now why would that be? Surely not embarrassment?
These figures all speak for themselves. Out of all the frauds and deceptions perpetrated by Access Ministries and the ACL, the mother of all lies is this steady stream of propaganda of overwhelming public support. This “support” just simply does not exist, and the endless proclamations to the contrary remind me of those of third world dictators boasting of their people’s love for them. Reality does not conform to delusion – the solution is to make noise that it does. And the greatest failure of our state and our system of government is that our politicians choose to believe them – lured by the serpent’s song that this will all somehow translate into votes.
I think you should inform your local members otherwise.
Footnote: On the main page activity wall there is a post from a mother regarding her concerns about Access’ activities at her childrens’ school. It was posted over a month ago. It has not had a single response.
Update 23 June (for the sake of Aragorn) –
I was pointed to an apparently Evonne Paddison moderated other Facebook Cause group –
which is hardly any more impressive. Another group flat-lining with single digit sign-ups that only make magical numbers like 98% approval seem so nonsensical –
Past Week
Date | Total Joins | Change from previous day |
---|---|---|
Tue, Jun 21 | 6 | -14.3% |
Mon, Jun 20 | 7 | +40.0% |
Sun, Jun 19 | 5 | 0 |
Sat, Jun 18 | 5 | -50.0% |
.
I mean really, this is Paddison’s own group. If anything, it makes the public support vacuum even more blatant. Total of 5 posts in the last month, 2 of them link spam from Nicholas Tuohy, one to a defunct Access Facebook page. Staggering.
June 21, 2011 at 4:07 pm
If they have so much support why are they trying to stop the questionnaire asking if parents support them ?
I guess they must feel sorry for us atheist and how ashamed we would feel when we find out they have been telling the truth and 98% of parents do support them 🙂
June 21, 2011 at 4:24 pm
Yes, their modesty is overwhelming. How can individuals have so much compassion and decency without exploding?
June 23, 2011 at 2:48 pm
I think you got the wrong group there. The Access sponsored FB Cause group has 3577 members (it has Evonne PAdison as one of the Admin). It has had about 1000 members join in the last 2 months.http://www.causes.com/causes/508902-vote-for-chaplaincy/impact
Also, the Scripture Union QLD support chaplaincy petition has almost 22,000 supporters. By comparison, the FIRIS campaign has around 525 likes on their FB page. While I appreciate you are trying to show how much support their is for the FIRIS campaign, it is not helping it to quote false information.
June 23, 2011 at 3:14 pm
The only way I found this group was via a link at the Access Ministries website. Their support page now lists nothing – not even your link. Also, the more vocal Access apologists, such as Nicholas Tuohy, were spamming for members to this same group.
Regardless, this other group you link is also flat-lining in low single digit signups with membership after the original burst when the first Facebook group closed. If you think this degree of disinterest is not at odds with the bogus statistics and indicative of the poll bombing tactics, beware of used car salesmen.
All the evidence points to Access consisting of a small core of maniacs using the frill-necked lizard tactic of making vast quantities of noise to create illusory levels of public approval. As with everything else Access, this is cheap self-promoting deception. How can a cause with even 3,500 members claim to represent 98% approval ratings as some of their propaganda suggests? They are liars and they are frauds and they have been caught over and over and over.
June 25, 2011 at 5:54 pm
Yes but you are naive if you think FIRIS supporters are not doing the same- we are. There is nothing inherently wrong with emailing your supporters and friends pointing them to a link such as a poll or a FB cause page. This is what everyone does. There is no good argument you are making by claiming Access have done this. SO what?
And when you refer to Access as “maniacs using the frill-necked lizard tactic” and “liars and they are frauds”, you make the FIRIS campaign look cheap and extremist. You will not find any such language about Access or its supporters on the FIRIS page. If you want to help the campaign be credible, then lifting the level of discourse and debate to a more civil and respectful tone would help. Otherwise the FIRIS cause gets lumped in with conspiracy theorists and blogging nutters. Moreover, the fact that you blog behind a pseudonym gives you no real credibility in the debate.
June 25, 2011 at 6:44 pm
PS- I apologise about the last sentence- I assume “Franc Hoggle” is not a real name, but is in fact a creation of Jim Henson- http://muppet.wikia.com/wiki/Hoggle
Sorry if it is your real name.